THE VANISHING TRUTH: CONFRONTING POLICE ABDUCTIONS AND THE QUEST FOR JUSTICE IN KENYA

This gripping narrative uncovers the disturbing reality of police abductions and mysterious disappearances in Kenya, revealing the courageous struggle for habeas corpus. It powerfully illuminates the human cost of these violations and the relentless fight for justice against a backdrop of systemic oppression. As it challenges readers to confront these uncomfortable truths, the story serves as a compelling call to action for human rights and accountability.
Over the past decade, Kenya has seen a disturbing rise in incidents of enforced disappearances and police-led abductions, often targeting individuals under suspicion of terrorism, activism, or criminal activity. These cases—frequently marked by unmarked vehicles, masked operatives, and total silence from authorities—have sparked growing alarm among human rights defenders. At the center of this constitutional crisis lies a powerful yet increasingly fragile legal remedy: habeas corpus.

The Legal Shield of Habeas Corpus

Habeas corpus is a legal order issued by a court demanding that a detained individual be brought before it to determine the legality of the detention. The term originates from Latin, meaning “you shall have the body.” In Kenya, this right is protected under Article 51 of the Constitution and is actionable through the High Court under Article 165 and Section 389 of the Criminal Procedure Code. It is designed to serve as a safeguard against arbitrary detention by the state.

However, its utility is under siege.

Case Studies: Lives Lost in the Shadows
  1. The Disappearance of Bashir Mohamed

In May 2021, Somali-American businessman Bashir Mohamed disappeared after leaving a Nairobi hotel. CCTV footage captured his abduction by individuals suspected to be state agents. His body was later discovered in Kirinyaga County, bearing signs of torture. Despite overwhelming public pressure and evidence, no one has been held accountable. A habeas corpus application was rendered moot after his death.

  1. The Kamiti Six

In 2021, six inmates escaped from Kamiti Maximum Security Prison under suspicious circumstances. Shortly after, security agencies launched a manhunt, and three of the escapees were reportedly abducted from their hideouts. While officials claimed re-arrest, rights groups noted the absence of due process or formal charges, calling into question the state’s respect for habeas corpus protections.

  1. The Abduction of Missing Mombasa Youths

In Mombasa and other coastal areas, Muslim youth have been disproportionately targeted. Dozens have vanished, many allegedly taken by the Anti-Terror Police Unit (ATPU). Despite numerous habeas corpus applications filed by civil society organizations, including MUHURI and Haki Africa, the state frequently denies custody, effectively neutralizing judicial inquiry.

Judicial Responses and Civil Society Pressure

Kenyan courts have intermittently responded by ordering state officials, including high-ranking police officers, to produce the missing persons or explain their whereabouts. However, compliance is inconsistent. In many cases, the state’s refusal to acknowledge custody frustrates enforcement.

Civil society actors have worked tirelessly to spotlight these disappearances. Yet without stronger judicial muscle and legislative enforcement, habeas corpus remains a blunt instrument against an entrenched culture of impunity.

Conclusion: The Cost of Silence

Habeas corpus remains one of the last standing bulwarks against unchecked state power. Yet without swift judicial enforcement, legislative support, and sustained public pressure, it risks becoming symbolic. The stories of Bashir Mohamed, the Mombasa youth, and others remind us that behind every file or court number is a family waiting—often in vain—for answers.

It is time to make the law work again. For those abducted. For those detained in silence. And for the rule of law in Kenya

In light of these troubling developments, D. Otunga & Associates Advocates has pledged unwavering support to victims of enforced disappearance and their families. The firm under the initiative titled “Bring Them Home: Legal Aid for the Missing” is aimed at:

  • Filing urgent habeas corpus applications on behalf of detained or disappeared individuals.
  • Working with civil society partners to investigate and document cases of unlawful detention.
  • Challenging state impunity through strategic litigation and constitutional petitions.
  • Offering psychosocial and legal support to families navigating the trauma and legal uncertainty of disappearances.

“The Constitution is clear: no Kenyan shall be held incommunicado. When the state breaks its laws, it is our duty—as lawyers and citizens—to fight back,” said Doreen Otunga, lead counsel and founder of the firm. “We encourage affected families to come forward. Silence only enables more disappearances.”

Scroll to Top